The Careful Use of Compliments

by: Alexander Mccall Smith

Published by: Anchor Books/Random House

Reviewed by Barbara L. Fielder

As a mystery reader, you may have discovered that some authors drop you squarely into their plot from paragraph one on their very first page with an adrenalin-pumping, fast-paced chase or dilemma. The characters, their motivation, focus and flaws are then revealed at key points in the story.

That being said, Alexander McCall Smith first earns your trust as he introduces you up front to each of his colorful and appealing characters. You discover all of their virtues, flaws and beguiling ways; then the author gently surrounds you in the mystery like a warm cozy blanket.

For Isabel Dalhousie fans, you’re in for a treat. In this mystery she is compelled to investigate an art world puzzle when the work of a well-known, but deceased artist, suddenly appears for auction. She follows her instincts to discover the truth behind the recent appearance of the rare art treasure, and who is surprisingly behind the move to sell the work.

The author completes the story by inviting you into Isabel’s personal life. Her life is a colorful combination of optimism, curiosity, and straight-forward dialog. Isabel has a healthy awareness of her fallacies, and deep love for her baby, Charlie. The baby’s father, Jamie, proposes marriage. However, Isabel cannot say yes as she is engaged in the web of intrigue, mystery and motherhood. There is no doubt she is in love with Jamie. The author provides a glimpse into their caring relationship to assure readers that Isabel and Jamie are doting parents and hold each other in high esteem. The vivid and charming dialog between the characters draws you more intimately into their story.

This easy-paced, captivating story is set in Edinburgh, Scotland; a mystery actually written for the faint-at-heart. The author gives you time to linger in the culture, absorb the beauty, and take in the breathtaking scenery as the mystery unfolds.

Does the art world puzzle consume Isabel? Yes, to a worthy and satisfactory outcome.

Armchair Interviews says: Enjoy this comfortable fireside read.

Author’s Web site: http://www.AlexanderMccallSmith.com